Does a New Roof Increase Home Value? What Realtors and Data Say

Introduction: Why Roof Condition Matters More Than You Think

When potential buyers pull up to your home, their first impression starts before they even walk inside—and your roof plays a starring role. A visibly aged or neglected roof can instantly raise red flags, while a brand-new one gives buyers confidence and peace of mind.

But does a new roof actually increase the resale value of your home, or does it simply keep buyers from walking away? Let’s take a closer look at what realtors, data, and industry pros have to say about roof ROI, buyer psychology, and when it’s actually worth investing in a new roof before selling.

1. What Realtors Say: A New Roof Preserves Value, Not Adds It

According to many real estate agents, a new roof won’t necessarily boost your listing price—but it can absolutely prevent a drop in offers. One experienced North Texas realtor put it simply: “A new roof doesn’t add value—it protects it.”

Here’s why:

• Buyers expect a functional roof. If it’s damaged or leaking, they’ll either walk away or demand a hefty credit during negotiations.
  
  
• Home inspections will flag roof issues. This can delay closing, impact buyer financing, or kill the deal entirely.
  
  
• Insurance may be denied. Many buyers won’t qualify for homeowners insurance if the roof is deemed too old or risky.
  
  
• Perception of upkeep. A worn-out roof can signal neglect and raise concerns about the rest of the home.
  
  

If you're planning to list soon, a great place to start is a free roof inspection to understand your roof’s condition before it becomes an issue for buyers.

2. What the Data Says: Real Roof ROI Stats

Replacing a roof is a major investment, so what kind of return can you expect?

According to the Remodeling 2023 Cost vs. Value Report:

• Asphalt shingles
  
  
  
  • Avg. cost: $22,636
    
    
  • Resale value increase: $15,247
    
    
  • ROI: ~68%
    
    
• Metal roofing
  
  
  
  • Avg. cost: $38,600
    
    
  • Resale value increase: $23,526
    
    
  • ROI: ~61%
    
    

In contrast, the National Association of the Remodeling Industry (NARI) reports that homeowners may recoup 109% ROI in competitive markets with older homes. Zillow research also shows that nearly 1 in 5 sellers repaired or replaced their roof before listing.

While it may not be a profit generator, a new roof can absolutely help you achieve full asking price, avoid concessions, and speed up the sale.

3. When It’s Worth Replacing Your Roof Before Selling

Not every home needs a new roof before listing—but certain situations make it a smart and necessary move.

Replace your roof if:

• It’s 15 years or older and showing signs of wear
  
  
• You’ve experienced recent hail or wind damage
  
  
• The roof is visibly patchy, sagging, or leaking
  
  
• Comparable homes nearby have newer or better-looking roofs
  
  
• You’ve had trouble selling or had negative buyer feedback about the roof
  
  

In North Texas and surrounding areas, where hail and storm damage are common, buyers are especially cautious. If your roof is a liability, it will show up in inspections, reduce buyer confidence, and lower offers.

You can learn more about whether it’s time in our blog on when to replace your roof.

4. Choosing the Right Roofing Material for Resale

Not all roof types are created equal—some add more perceived value, curb appeal, and buyer confidence than others.

Asphalt Shingles

• Most affordable and common in Texas
  
  
• Lifespan: 20–30 years
  
  
• ROI: 60–70%
  
  
• Match nearly any home style
  
  

Metal Roofing

• Durable and efficient, with a 40–70 year lifespan
  
  
• ROI: 50–65%
  
  
• Great for energy savings and weather resistance
  
  

Tile or Clay

• Long-lasting and beautiful in the right climate
  
  
• Costly, heavy, and typically reserved for luxury homes
  
  
• Best suited for upscale or Spanish-style architecture
  
  

Slate

• Premium appeal and 100+ year durability
  
  
• Not ideal unless your home and neighborhood support the price point
  
  

To explore what might work best for your property, visit our roof replacement service page for expert advice on choosing the right material for your home and market.

5. Boosting Curb Appeal Without Full Replacement

If your roof doesn’t require replacement, you can still make cost-effective updates that enhance your home’s marketability.

Easy visual upgrades:

• Replace a few missing or curling shingles
  
  
• Power wash the roof to remove algae or debris
  
  
• Paint metal vents and flashing for a fresh look
  
  
• Clean gutters and ensure proper drainage
  
  
• Reseal skylights or chimneys to prevent leaks
  
  

These quick fixes can complement other exterior upgrades, like new siding or windows. In fact, if your home needs broader updates, check out our services for exterior renovations.

6. Legal Disclosures and Inspection Requirements

If your roof is in poor condition, it's not just an inconvenience—it could create legal or financing problems.

Key legal and financial concerns:

• Disclosure laws: In Texas, sellers are required to disclose known roof issues.
  
  
• Financing delays: FHA and VA loans often require the roof to have at least 2 years of life.
  
  
• Insurance risks: Buyers may struggle to insure a home with an aging or damaged roof.
  
  

The best way to stay ahead of these concerns? A licensed roof inspection. Not only does it give you clarity, but it also provides documentation to reassure buyers.

Learn more about our detailed roof inspection process and how it fits into your selling strategy.

7. Bonus Benefits of a New Roof

Still debating? Here are additional reasons why a roof upgrade may be the right move:

• Faster sale: Homes with updated roofs spend less time on the market.
  
  
• Higher confidence: Buyers feel more comfortable submitting strong offers.
  
  
• Stronger listing photos: A clean roof improves your home’s online presentation.
  
  
• Energy efficiency: Modern materials can reduce energy bills and attract eco-conscious buyers.
  
  
• Transferable warranty: Offering a transferable roofing warranty can sweeten the deal for buyers.
  
  

Plus, new roofs can complement other improvements like gutters, fascia, and even storm damage restoration—especially after a major weather event.

8. Final Thoughts: Should You Replace Your Roof?

A new roof may not always be the flashiest upgrade, but it’s often one of the most strategic—especially when your current one is a risk to the sale.

By replacing a roof before listing, you can:

• Eliminate buyer objections early
  
  
• Avoid post-inspection negotiations or price cuts
  
  
• Support full asking price with confidence
  
  
• Help buyers get through insurance and financing approvals
  
  

If your roof is in good shape, small repairs and a professional cleaning may be enough. But if it's aging, leaking, or an eyesore, a full replacement might be your ticket to a faster and more profitable home sale.

‍